US/Canada Graduate School Application Process - Frequently Asked Questions

(Eran Chinthaka Withana, Saliya Ekanayake, Yoshani De Silva)

Disclaimer: Answers to these questions are from the experiences of the authors of this article and are highly subjective. Certain answers can be invalid for certain scenarios.

What are the steps of PhD application process?

PhD application process is a tedious process that can take 6 months to even 1 and half years. Here is a list of things you need to be doing during this process in no particular order.

Which tests do I need to take?

Most  universities require you to take either or both GRE and TOEFL exams. Refer to university graduate school website to find out their requirements. But its a good idea to do get ready and sit for the exams if you are planning to apply for multiple universities. There are universities that do not require either of these exams. But those are often highly competitive and your chances of selection can be low compared to  others.

What is considered to be a good GRE score?

GRE exam mainly consists of an analytical section and a verbal section. Analytical section tests your mathematical skills and verbal section tests your english language skills. It is highly recommended to achieve more than 750 (out of 800) in analytical exams, but getting 800 can be a big plus. If you have less than 700, you have very low chance of getting through the first screening.

Most schools understand that verbal section is really hard and they don't want you to excel in that. Getting  more than 350 is generally considered okay for this section. But you need to prove your English skills with better TOEFL score.

Where can I do my GRE and TOEFL exams?

As of this writing,in Sri Lanka they offer paper based GRE exams once a year. But in India they have internet based exams on a regular basis. If you cannot sit for the paper based exams in Sri Lanka or you have  a low score, going to India and getting your exams done is a good alternative.

Can I directly apply for a PhD after my undergraduate degree?

Short answer is, in US - Yes !! in Canada - No !!

You can directly apply for a PhD after your undergraduate degree if its a US school. During your first few years you will be taking courses to fulfil your PhD qualification. These subjects are (almost) equivalent to a master degree.

In Canada, most of the universities require you to have a masters degree to apply for a PhD. There are cases where few students are taken directly into the PhD program but this is rare and these students tend to have an exceptional academic and research record, also often having prior experience with the lab they are applying to.

How long does it take to complete the PhD?

Answer to this question depends on numerous factors. It can depend on your skills, your advisor, your area of research, your research lab, your rate of publications, your school, your department procedures and little bit of luck. In general it can take from 3.5 years upto 10 years, but on average its about 5 to 6 years.

Which universities should I apply?

This depends on the area of research you are interested in. Search for university labs that have research in your area of interest. Read papers published in those labs and send emails to the faculties in that lab. Make sure you show interest in the work they are doing.

Selecting universities purely based on ranking can be misguiding. University ranking process is an ad-hoc process and depends on numerous factors. A leader in a certain field can have a lab in a small university. Also, general university rankings can be different from the subject area based ranking. For example, a university having a low general rank can have a higher rank in programming languages. Its always a good idea to select at least 2 universities from rankings 1-15 and 15-45 and 45-100.

Why should I apply for graduate school?

This is a highly subjective question. People apply for graduate school for various reasons. Some are really passionate about a field and they want to learn and research more on that area. Some want to become faculties or teach in university and they need a PhD. Some require a PhD to get a better job. Some pursue a PhD to get into other countries and live a better life. Some pursue a PhD because his/her friend or relative is doing that.

Whatever the reason, PhD process can be tough. You will have to go through a hard time to fulfil the requirements and get through the process. Unless you are passionate about what you are doing it can be hard to survive. There are people who have given up PhD in the middle of the program (no I'm not talking about people who went on to start companies and got wealthy :D). But having said that I personally believe most of our students can go through this pain and get a PhD :)

Do I need to be exceptional to apply for graduate school?

Not really. If you are passionate about what you want to do and you think you can do it no matter how hard it gets then you are good enough. From my experience interacting with undergraduate students in Sri Lanka and in other countries I really believe our students can do it. Most of our students have the passion to do it. Remember when you are about to go for industrial training you were scared about working upto the company expectations? But didn't you complete your internship without any issue?

Where can I get recommendations for my PhD application?

A recommendation letter will be one of the main documents they will consider during PhD application process. It really recommends you and talks about your research ability from some one else's point of view. For this recommendation to be credible he or she must also have a credibility or credible record. So its really important to select the recommenders carefully. I've seen two types of people you should avoid at all cost for getting recommendations.

  1. People who have not published recently:: There are people that are famous in the home country, who you think are recognized and acceptable in your university and therefore should be good to get recommendations. But don't forget that your recommendations are evaluated by a committee outside Sri Lanka ( in US or Canada!). They will search for your recommender and will find out  who he is and what he is doing. If he hasn't published a research paper for ages I'd avoid him. People who haven't published papers or haven't done significant research contributions recently should be avoided.
  2. People who give negative recommendations: Its hard to believe but certain faculties have done this. The recommendation will be directly sent to your university by your recommender and you can not look review it beforehand.. When a recommendation is supposed to boost your application if a faculty mentions that you are NOT suitable for any kinds of research studies it will look negative on your entire application.  So make sure you get recommendations from the people whom you know for sure will give good recommendations and who know about your research experience.

How do I get funding for PhD?

There are few funding resources available for a PhD student.

Can I bring my family with me if I'm selected?

Definitely yes, in fact you should (what’s the point of having a family if you cannot be with them at all the times :) ). You can work with the selected university to get dependent visa for your wife and kids. Certain visa types even allow your wife to work when you are here.

Can I work part time when I come to study in US?

You are allowed to work on campus for 20hrs per week within Fall and Spring semesters. During summer you can work on a place related to your academic work for 40hrs or more in a week. All the other employments will be considered illegal for students on student visa.

What should be included in Statement of Purpose?

Statement of Purpose (SOP) will be the marketing documents that will sell yourself to different universities. If you are not in contact with any of the faculties, the university committee and other interested faculties will read the SOP to consider yourself to their university or lab. Here are few things you can include in this document:

  1. Your past research experience: Include what you did for your final year undergraduate project. List any papers you published on this work or any other work. If you don't have a technical paper written from your final year project, this is the best time to write it and put on the web. Write about challenging research questions you worked in the past.
  2. Your passion for research: Select one or two research areas and mention how passionate you are. You can include an example like something you did or saw in your childhood and how it inspired you to learn and research more on that subject. Explain how you are curious about certain things in your area and include how you think you can contribute to improve them.
  3. Your connection to research in the university/lab: This is one of the most important things. This section will be different from university to university. For a given university, find the research labs working on your related area. Read few papers published in that lab and think about how those are related to what you are doing and how you think you can contribute to further their research. Write them down in this section and don't forget to reference the related research papers. Professors in universities love to see someone is interested in their research and thinking about it now itself. If you can do a better job in this section you will have a better chance of getting selected. At the same time make sure your suggestions for improvements in their research make sense.

When should I apply and what are other time constraints?

It is very important to adhere to application deadlines when applying to graduate studies. Usually deadlines for Fall applications are between early December (of the year before) and mid of January. Different universities have different dates. So make sure you keep track of them appropriately and apply well in time. This is easier said than done if you are not prepared with the prerequisites that you would encounter while applying. A set of possible time constraints are explained under the following points.

How much does the application process cost?

The application process has two main expenses; i.e. application fee and fees for tests (e.g. GRE, TOEFL). The following is a rough break down of prices for these.

In total if you apply to only four universities you are looking for something around,

(50 to 100 taken as 75 on average) x 4 + 190 + 150 = $640 (without other expenses)

How do I know whether graduate school is for me?

Graduate school is about doing full-time research for 2 years if it’s a Masters or for 4+ years if its for a PhD.  Get a flavour for what is involved by doing research projects and getting experience in your undergraduate years.  The sooner you can do this, the better it is.  Also talk to graduate students in your school and abroad.  Read research papers and staff/lab profiles to understand the kinds of research taking place and what is involved in a graduate degree.  Refer to the section on “Why should I apply to Graduate school”.  If you like research work, graduate school is an option to get into after you complete your undergraduate degree – but you have to start planning early.

Should I apply for MS or PhD?  Is it easy to get funding for both?

If you’re interested in doing a shorter research oriented degree, go for the MS, since its 2 years.  Some universities offer a non-thesis (course based) MS which is also 2 years. If you plan to do the PhD (4+ years) or you need it for your dream job, its better to apply directly to the PhD.  If you change your mind while doing the PhD, you can still leave early with a terminal MS.

In US, most MS degrees are not funded.  On the other hand, almost all PhDs are fully funded.

In Canada, almost all thesis-based MS degrees are fully funded and PhDs are also funded.

Can I choose a different field for MS/PhD compared to what I did for BS?

Yes you can.  Having the theoretical knowledge in different fields can be to your advantage since many professors these days are involved in multi-disciplinary and collaborative research projects.  But it is better to have research experience in the field or program you are planning to apply to since you can show your potential supervisor why you deserve to get the acceptance as a graduate student in his or her lab.

What if I have a general degree, the only research experience I have is a literature survey or if I have a second lower?  Can I still apply for PhD or should I give up on it?  What can I do to boost my application?

You can still apply but you have to be careful about the schools you select.  It is better to try, than to give up!  Instead of applying to highly competitive, top-ranked universities, you should apply to the lower ranked ones.  Later on, maybe after getting a terminal MS or if you consider doing a post-doc for instance, you can consider transferring to another university.  In your SOP, you can explain why you have lower grades.  To boost your application you should get involved in as many research projects as possible and highlight this in your SOP.  If you can get involved in presentations, conferences and have publications, this will help your application.  Also, read your potential supervisor’s publications well and try to propose additional innovative ideas that can be added to their studies.  Do everything you can to show that you are totally into what they are doing and impress them!

You can also take external qualifications such as CIM and CIMA, and use those additional certificates and grades to boost your average.  If you are applying to the US, you can send all of your transcripts to World Education Service (WES – www.wes.org ) where foreign credentials are evaluated and they will provide a cumulative assessment.

In the US and Canada, are there specific states and schools that are good to apply for CS?

In Canada, University of Toronto, University of British Columbia, Waterloo University and McGill University are all highly ranked for CS and Engineering programs. These are very competitive. Other universities to consider are University of Alberta, University of Calgary, University of Manitoba, Queens University and McMaster University.

In US it depends on the area of research you are interested. The top 10 universities in US can be good for any research area but after that point the rankings depend on the field. Do some research on labs in different universities.